ERC President’s speech ‘Research investment and European capabilities’

23 October 2026
The ERC President, Maria Leptin, delivered a speech at the CESEAR Annual Meetings with the overall theme 'Critical technologies for Europe: From excellence to capability', in Lisbon.
Maria Leptin

Check against delivery

Dear Orla Feely, dear Karin Markides, dear colleagues,

Thank you for inviting me to join you here in Lisbon, and to Instituto Superior Técnico for hosting us. Many of your universities are home to European Research Council grantees, and you know from experience what these grants make possible. So I would like to begin with something we have been doing together, and which I think deserves more recognition.

Throughout the discussions on the next longterm EU budget, the research community has maintained a common position. Organisations representing different institutions and different parts of the research system have repeatedly come together to ask for an ambitious framework programme, with at least €200 billion for Horizon Europe.

That is more than the European Commission has proposed, and considerably more than many people thought it realistic to ask for when these discussions began. It is worth remembering that, because we are now entering the stage when everybody will be encouraged to lower their expectations.

In 2023 and early 2024, there were understandable reasons for pessimism. Russia's war against Ukraine, energy costs and the need to strengthen European defence were putting pressure on public finances. Research would have to compete with demands that governments regarded as immediate and unavoidable. In that atmosphere, even maintaining our position could seem ambitious.

But the ERC Scientific Council thought we should make the case for what Europe needed. In January 2024, we called for a doubling of the budget for research and innovation in the next framework programme. We argued that Europe's scientific position, its economy and its security were connected, and that allowing our research capacity to fall behind would make the other problems harder to address.

The ERC does not sign the joint statements issued by your associations, but we have been arguing in the same direction. And the position the community has maintained matters precisely because it goes beyond the interests of any one instrument or group of institutions.

Each of us could have begun by explaining why our own favoured part of the programme deserved a larger share. Instead, the organisations have continued to make a case for a larger investment overall. That gives governments a different question to answer. They have to consider whether Europe is investing enough to achieve its stated aims, rather than simply choosing between competing requests from researchers.

The Mario Draghi report gave this argument further weight. It explained why Europe would struggle to preserve its social commitments and independence without improving productivity and innovation, and it made a strong case for fundamental research. The Commission subsequently proposed €175 billion for the next Horizon Europe, including a substantial strengthening of the ERC.

We cannot attribute that proposal to any single intervention. But we should recognise how far the discussion moved, and be careful about giving up the ambition that helped move it. The community asked governments to take research more seriously as an investment in Europe's future, and the Commission put forward a proposal reflecting that ambition.

Now we have the Irish EU Presidency's negotiating proposal, with almost €17 billion less for Horizon Europe than the Commission proposed, and reductions to the European Competitiveness Fund as well. These are proposals under negotiation, and I do not think our response should be to start deciding which parts of our community can afford to lose.

Our common position remains justified. The needs that led us to ask for €200 billion have not diminished because a smaller figure has appeared in a negotiating document. We should continue to explain those needs together, especially to the governments that will decide the budget.

Nor should we assume that the political attention given to technology will protect its funding. The proposed reductions affect industrial innovation as well as research. Calling an activity strategic does not settle the budget argument, as we can now see. We still have to persuade governments that the investment is necessary, and that postponing it carries costs of its own.

Your meeting's theme gives us a good way to do that. Europe needs capabilities in critical technologies, and universities have much to contribute. But I would like us to think about how we make that contribution understood, because the argument we choose now may shape what governments expect of us for many years.

One concern is that frontier research will appear too distant from technological priorities to deserve sustained support. We certainly need to correct that impression, and we have substantial evidence with which to do so.

Our recent mapping of advanced materials research identified more than 1,500 ERC projects funded between 2014 and 2023. Our biotechnology analysis identified more than 2,400 projects over the same period. An earlier report examined more than 1,000 projects developing or using artificial intelligence, or investigating its implications. Alongside these published reports we have also identified internally substantial portfolios of projects connected to other critical technologies.

The boundaries between these areas often overlap, just as they do in your universities. But we can identify a considerable body of relevant research. The ERC's contribution to technologies that matter to Europe is already visible, even though we did not select these projects through calls devoted to those technologies.

That last point is important. The researchers proposed their questions and independent experts judged their scientific ambition and quality. The resulting portfolio contains work that can contribute to today's priorities, alongside work opening possibilities that we do not yet know how to describe in policy terms.

This also allows researchers to approach a problem from directions that a funding authority might not have considered. A difficulty in one field can become tractable because somebody develops a method in another. Restricting the range of questions we support can therefore reduce the opportunities available even within the areas we have decided to prioritise.

We should make those contributions better known. But if we stop there, we risk suggesting that the case for the ERC depends on how much of its portfolio can be attached to the current list of critical technologies. And I think that would give an incomplete account of both the ERC and your universities.

Let me explain why, starting with the technologies themselves.

Being able to identify research relevant to a technology does not mean we can promise industrial leadership in it. Between a scientific result and a capability that Europe can use, there may be difficult engineering problems, manufacturing requirements and investment decisions. There must be organisations able to develop the work, and customers willing to use what they produce.

Many of you work with these difficulties every day. You know that a promising material can perform well in the laboratory and prove difficult to manufacture consistently. A company may have a technology that works but struggle to finance its first production facility. More research funding cannot, by itself, resolve every obstacle along that route.

So we should explain what universities can contribute without taking responsibility for everything that determines the eventual outcome. If we promise that investment in a research programme will produce European leadership in a particular industry, we may be promising something that depends on decisions far beyond that programme.

So what, beyond individual technologies, are we asking governments to invest in? I think we can give them a much fuller answer, starting with the people who do the research.

Consider Arthur Mensch, one of the founders of Mistral AI. Before working at DeepMind and then co-founding Mistral, he was a postdoctoral researcher on Gabriel Peyré's ERC-funded NORIA project, working on mathematical methods with applications in imaging and machine learning.

I am pleased that we can point to that ERC connection. But the useful lesson is that his experience in research was part of the preparation he took into industry. We could not have specified the company he would help establish when the project was funded, and it would be unreasonable to expect every researcher trained on such a project to establish one.

Most will contribute in less conspicuous ways. Somebody joining an established company may help it understand a new method, recognise a technical opportunity or abandon an approach that will not work. That can be valuable without producing a story that reaches the newspapers.

And this happens throughout your institutions. Research produces knowledge that others can build on, and people who know how to work with it. It develops instruments and methods that can be used for purposes beyond the original question. It creates relationships through which people can seek advice, exchange experience and solve problems together.

We have known about these contributions for a long time and there are many different channels through which public research benefits the economy. They include trained people, new methods, networks and greater problem-solving capacity, as well as knowledge and new firms.

Yet these contributions are easily lost when we choose only our most spectacular examples. We describe the breakthrough or the successful company, and leave out much of what sustained research has made possible along the way.

In particular, research helps us to use knowledge produced elsewhere. For any European country, most research takes place beyond its borders. Even Europe as a whole will produce only part of the knowledge that its companies and public institutions need. We have to be able to understand and use what others discover.

A manufacturer considering a new process needs engineers who can judge whether it will work under different conditions. A public authority buying a technical system needs enough expertise to question the supplier. Those abilities develop through demanding work, including research in which people learn to investigate a problem whose answer is uncertain.

This is particularly relevant to universities, where teaching, research and engineering meet. Students learn from people working with questions that have not been settled. Technical staff develop knowledge that may never be fully written down. Collaborations allow that experience to travel between laboratories and into other organisations.

An ERC grant benefits from that environment and contributes to it. The team depends on facilities, colleagues and expertise around it, while its own work gives others new ideas and opportunities. You see these connections within your institutions, even when a project report cannot capture them all.

So when we discuss Europe's technological capability, we should keep this wider contribution in view. We need discoveries and companies able to develop them, and we also need people throughout the economy who can assess, adapt and improve technologies. A list of priority projects cannot describe all the work that develops those abilities.

And our responsibilities extend further still. Research helps us understand economic change, political institutions and the societies in which technologies are used. History and the humanities allow us to examine our assumptions and question convenient explanations. These are reasons for supporting research in their own right, alongside the contribution it makes to technological development.

The breadth of the ERC portfolio reflects that understanding. Supporting ambitious research across disciplines gives Europe opportunities to pursue questions that have not yet attracted political attention, and to understand problems that cannot be reduced to technological ones. That breadth is something we should explain and defend.

I have spent time on this because it brings us back to the common position with which I began. The research system contributes through many connected activities, and the budget should sustain those connections. Universities need frontier research, collaborative programmes and research infrastructures, as well as opportunities for people to develop their careers and move between institutions.

New arrangements can help, and I understand the interest in the European Competitiveness Fund. Europe needs better support for promising technologies to develop and reach use. But that requires us to ask quite concrete questions about how the arrangements will work, who will make decisions and how support will reach the people and organisations that need it.

Supporting the ambition of a new fund does not answer those questions. Its eventual contribution will depend on the design and implementation. The experience we have gained from existing programmes should inform those decisions, including our experience of what independent scientific judgement makes possible.

In the ERC, we have a clear purpose and an established process that researchers understand. We can examine what it has supported, learn from its results and improve how it operates. Your institutions have helped make that possible by hosting the researchers and providing the environments in which their work develops.

That experience is valuable as Europe changes its funding arrangements. We should build on it while continuing to argue for the resources the whole system needs. There is still a negotiation to influence, and the common position your organisations have maintained gives you a basis for doing so.

I would therefore ask you to take this argument into your national capitals. Many of you can speak directly to ministers and their advisers. Please explain what the proposed investment would enable, drawing on the work in your universities, and what opportunities would be lost if Europe reduced its ambition.

The examples need not all be exceptional success stories. You can show how research develops the people an industry needs, how a shared facility allows several institutions to do work they could not undertake alone, or how expertise in your university helps a public body make a better decision. These are concrete contributions that a government can understand.

You can also explain how you judge the quality of that work. Asking for more investment brings a responsibility to account for how it is used, and to recognise where arrangements need to improve. 

And please keep making the European argument. National investment supports the institutions in which research takes place while European funding allows them to compete and collaborate across a much larger community. Neither can substitute for the other, and the benefits of their work extend beyond the country receiving a grant.

This also means challenging the way governments calculate what they get back from the European budget. Some Member States that invest relatively little in research have achieved rapid growth partly by attracting foreign investment and adopting technologies and practices developed elsewhere. They benefit from the knowledge Europe produces, even when they receive relatively few framework programme grants. We should certainly help them strengthen their research systems and participation, but we should also explain that grant receipts are a poor measure of their interest in European research. A country catching up has a considerable stake in the continued development of the knowledge it can use from elsewhere. Cutting that investment may therefore cost it much more in future opportunities than it appears to save in its net budget contribution.

We have good reasons, then, to maintain our common ambition. Critical technologies are part of that case, but universities and the research system offer Europe more than any current list of technologies can express. We should give governments that fuller account, and continue asking them to invest accordingly.

If, in the end, reductions cannot be prevented, there will be difficult choices to make. Those choices should be guided by evidence about what works, and by an understanding of the capabilities that would be lost. We should be particularly careful to preserve programmes whose purpose is clear and whose contribution has been demonstrated, as we develop new instruments whose results are still to come.

But we have not reached the end of this negotiation. The community has sustained a united and ambitious position, and I hope we will continue to do so. The reasons we had for asking Europe to invest more in research remain just as strong today.

Thank you.

Title
Press contact

Body

Madeleine Drielsma
Media Adviser to the ERC President
T: +32 2 298 76 31